C.E. "Bud" Brann
Staff Writer
cebrann@ruraltel.net
People who support burning the American flag say it’s no big deal; it is just a “bit of cloth”. If it is just “a bit of cloth”, what is the point of burning it? You might just as well burn your old underpants, mightn’t you?
Of course it’s more than a bit of cloth. It’s a symbol. If it were not a symbol, not more than a bit of cloth, no one would be interested in burning it.
It is a symbol of victory, and a symbol of defeat. When Marines faced a hail of bullets to raise that “bit of cloth” on Mt. Suribachi in Iwo Jima, it told the world of pride, bravery, effort, loss, blood, sweat, and tears…… and it told of victory.
When it was lowered in Viet Nam, it told the world of defeat and shame. The first act at a new embassy is to raise that “bit of cloth” and the last act when leaving an embassy is to lower that “bit of cloth.”
When America’s gold medal Olympic athletes wrap that bit of cloth around their shoulders as they take a victory lap, or when they stand at attention on the podium as their flag is raised, often with tears of pride in their eyes, it is not just a bit of cloth. It is a symbol of their pride in their country and in their achievement, just as are the flags of gold medal winners from every other country.
It is that bit of cloth which can cause thousands of noisy people at a football game, baseball game, or any other sporting event to suddenly become quiet, stand on their feet, and place their hand over their heart. I doubt if raising your old underwear on a stick would elicit that response. (Well I suppose if it were Pam Anderson’s under pants it might get some men to react that way.)
America is not a perfect country. It never has been and never will be. But millions of people from all over the world have come to the United States because they see that “bit of cloth” as a symbol for their hopes and desires, for a better future for themselves and for their children..
A “bit of cloth? No way!
The Statue of Liberty is not a “bit of metal”. It is a symbol, a symbol of hope for all “the poor and huddled masses yearning to be free.”
The Constitution and the Declaration of Independence are not just “bits of paper.” A marriage license, a diploma, a deed for your home are not just bits of paper. They are symbols, symbols which have meaning. Symbols of love, achievement, ownership. Symbols of hard work, sacrifice, yearning, hope, and pride.
The tomb of the Unknown Soldier, the Viet Nam wall, and for that matter the Blarney Stone, are not just “bits of stone”. They too are symbols. Symbols of love and respect; or symbols of loss, symbols of gain, and symbols of hope.
Standing by the Viet Nam wall, one sees many tears. The only reason your old underpants might bring a tear to the eye could be because of the smell.
Having said all that, you might assume I am a super patriot who supports an amendment to the constitution to prevent burning of the flag. I’m not and I do not. Just as we raise and wave the flag to indicate our pride, those who disagree with the actions of the government have the right, or should have the right, to use that same symbol as an example of their shame, their disagreement with government actions. I have yet to see a flag burner with whom I agreed, but one of the symbols for which our flag stands is freedom of speech and freedom of expression. They have the right to burn the flag, just as I have the right to tell them how I feel about their silly and childish means of protest. I would no more take that right from them, than I would allow them to take away my right to disagree with them.
Should President Bush be arrested for desecrating the flag by autographing it, as he has done? Should athletes, and entertainers, and Mr. and Mrs. American be arrested for wearing clothing representing our flag? Should the flag be painted on the side of race cars?
More importantly, doesn’t our government have more important things to do than interfere with people’s right of expression?
We are up to our ears in debt and sinking deeper by the hour. We are hated by much of the world. Our health care is a shambles; our old folks are being ill cared for. (Particularly a concern of mine as I am one.) We are in a war with Islamic terrorists. We appear to be mired in a war in Iraqi and possibly Afghanistan with no end in sight. We are threatened by Iran and North Korea.
Doesn’t our government have more important things to do then interfere with people’s right to expression, to interfere with the happiness of gay people, to thrust their personal religious belief on everyone else?
There was a time when it was conservatives who believed in rugged individualism, individual rights and freedoms and small government. It was, conservatives said, liberals who supported big government, group think, and interference with the many, in favor of the few. Now, in those respects there isn’t a nickels worth of difference between right and left. Both do the same, just from opposite sides of the coin.
We need to once again develop common goals, to learn to cooperate, not “out shout” each other, and see who can do the best job of interfering with others rights, just because we disapprove of them.
Before we can do this, we need to do something to keep our politicians from, every election year, trotting out old useless issues which do nothing but inflame passions. We need to demand that election rhetoric stick to important issues. Frankly I am sick of the Republicans trotting out the abortion issue every election and the Democrats trotting out racism every election. A pox on both your houses. Tell us how to defeat Islamic terrorism, tell us how to solve our health care crisis, the Social Security crisis. Tell us what you will do to solve the budget deficit. Simply griping that the other side is doing it all wrong doesn’t help. Tell us what you will do, not what the other guys is doing wrong.
People have the right to burn the American flag. We might wish they were wrapped in it at the time. Then maybe, just maybe, it would be your responsibility, as well as your right, to piss on them to put out the fire.
Now let’s get on with the business of the country.